La Fondita is a great little find in Amagansett. It’s a Mexican restaurant, predominantly for take out, but with picnic tables outside, weather permitting. What sets this take out place apart from others is that it’s owned by the same people as Nick & Toni’s in East Hampton, hands down one of the best restaurants in all the Hamptons. You can be sure the ingredients are fresh and the cooks behind the line know what they’re doing. It may not look like much from the outside. But one doesn’t necessarily go there for the ambiance. You go for the food. Place your order at the counter, get a number, wait to be called, grab a Mexican beer or horchata (cinnamon rice milk) if you’d like, and dig in. No frills. Just good food.
La Fondita’s menu has a little something for everyone looking for authentic Mexican and Latin flavors. The old stand-bys are included of course: tacos, burritos, quesadillas, nachos, etc. But what makes this place stand out is that they give you choices of meat or vegetarian style meals. There are also vegan entrées and the meat and poultry are all natural and antibiotic-free. The delicious corn is from Balsam Farms (one of my favorite farms locally). Each tortilla is made fresh daily.
At La Fondita, you don’t get one kind of taco, you get a choice of four, from your traditional meat tacos to fresh fish tacos. There are burritos with cod or shrimp when in season. There are soups (I love the pozole rojo: pork with white hominy topped with lettuce and radish), sandwiches, salads and sides, plus a children’s menu.
The prices at La Fondita are reasonable by Hamptons standards. For example, a fish taco is $4. Sandwiches are $9.50. And large, traditional plates such as chayote en salsa verde (squash in salsa verde) is $14.50. The portions are generally a good size, so order several items from the menu and share family style. Don’t forget their Mexican corn off the cob with red peppers, onion, cilantro, mayo, queso fresco, and chili powder when in season, $3.
Service is knowledgable, fast and friendly. The perfect place for super casual attire or take out. Call for off season hours or for catering your next fiesta: 631.324.6932.